This, milord, is my family's axe. We have owned it for almost nine hundred years, see. Of course, sometimes it needed a new blade. And sometimes it has required a new handle, new designs on the metalwork, a little refreshing of the ornamentation . . . but is this not the nine hundred-year-old axe of my family? And because it has changed gently over time, it is still a pretty good axe, y'know. Pretty good.I mean, this is as nice a common sense defence of the piece, but in the context of the book, it is really excellent.*
Anyway, I planned just to post the above, until I was looking for the quotation and found it on a page about the Ship of Theseus. I knew the axe thing was an old philosophical question, but I didn't know the specifics, and now I do.
The Ship of Theseus - is it the same after all the bits are replaced? - is the Ur-formulation of this question (in the western canon, anyway). John Locke's example was to do with his socks (all his postulations rhymed with his name). The French have Jeannot's Knife. The American's have George Washington's axe and so do I. I wonder what I could get for it on the open market?
Because I am a moron, I had never really considered how this is analogous to the whole problem of stepping in the same river twice. It is also the root of some philosophical problems involving matter transference. Is a teleported thing the same thing? (I have never been the same since I teleported.)
*I have a long term plan to blog about Pratchett's books in chronological order. You must be thrilled about this.
2 comments:
There's the Philosopher's Axe. And Trigger's Broom, of course.
What a great miracle I have ever seen, my breast cancer stage 4 has just been cured after using a herbal detox from herbalist morata. I was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2018. It has really been a problem for me and my family. I have been to many hospitals and spent 10,000 dollars all to know avail. On my research on the internet I came across a testimony of a lady called Monica Harris, she was testifying about Dr Morata healing medicine curing her cancer the email and WhatsApp contact of the doctor was also there.
I made contact with him by mail, and we had a little conversation. He asked for a few of my details which I sent to him, i made an order from him to cure my breast cancer as well. three days of making order , i receive the medication from fedEx, i was very happy because i believe i will be cured with this herbal medicine sent from dr morata, i used the medicine the same way dr morata instructed.few weeks later of using the medicine my cancer was gone, i was surprise and even went to my dr for proper checkup which was confirm negative. you can also contact him on behalf of your illness that hospitals couldn't cure dr morata can help. contact him herbalistmorata@gmail.com WhatsApp +2349028574982 or mail me for more information maryjudith709@gmail.com
Post a Comment